1.Clay particles / Mineral particles (the most common)
Advantages:
- Excellent heat resistance, safe for microwave oven heating
- Strong heat retention, long insulation time
- Moderate cost,Not prone to deterioration
Disadvantages:
- Heavy weight, rough texture
- Uneven heating, prone to local overheating
- Cannot be exposed to water, prone to cracking after getting wet
2. Natural grains (wheat, buckwheat, oats, millet)
Advantages:
- Soft and comfortable, with high heat application comfort
- Has a faint grainy aroma after heating, providing a good therapeutic effect
- Affordable price, with readily available materials
- Disadvantages:
- Prone to moisture, mold, and insect infestation
- Will char and carbonize after repeated long-term heating
- Generally short insulation time, and cools down quickly
3. Flaxseeds / Rapeseeds
Advantages:
- It is softer and more fluid than ordinary grains.
- It has better heat retention than grains, and retains heat for a longer time.
- The hot application feels warm and moist, suitable for joint areas.
- Disadvantages:
- The cost is higher than that of ordinary grains.
- It is also prone to moisture, and will have an oily smell after a long time.
- The heating time should not be too long, otherwise it will seep oil.
4. Silicone / Gel Type (Microwave Compatible)
Advantages:
- Extremely soft and comfortable, fitting the body
- Uniform heating, not likely to cause burns
- Does not mold or get infested with insects, can be used repeatedly for a long time
Disadvantages:
- High material cost
- Poor-quality gel decomposes easily at high temperatures and has a smell
- The insulation is not as long-lasting as mineral particles
5. Tuffstone / Pearl Rock (Lightweight Heat Storage Model)
Advantages:
- Light weight, portable
- Quick heating, stable heat storage
- No mold growth, no insect infestation
Disadvantages:
- Strong particle texture, relatively hard to the touch
- Easily crushed into powder upon impact
- Susceptible to compression during international shipping
6. Water + Antifreeze (a few microwaveable hot water bags)
Advantages:
- The temperature is the most gentle, similar to that of a hot water bag.
- The softness is the best.
Disadvantages:
- There is a high risk of explosion when heated in a microwave oven, as it is prone to expand.
- It is not recommended in most regions due to significant safety hazards.
Quick selection summary
- For high cost-effectiveness and the most recognition in the European and American markets: choose flaxseed over wheat.
- For durability, long-lasting insulation, and resistance to mold: choose clay particles / mineral particles.
- For softness, safety, and a premium style: choose food-grade microwave gel.
- Not recommended: water-based products, ordinary vermiculite (fragile and has many negative reviews).